Skip to content

Somewhere in These Pages

  • Books by MoodExpand
    • Emotional
    • Atmospheric
    • Explore All Books by Mood
  • Books by EraExpand
    • Explore All Books By Era
  • Books By LocationExpand
    • Books Set in Spain
    • Books Set in Japan
    • Books Set in Greece
    • Books Set in Turkey
    • Explore All Books By Place
  • Books by GenreExpand
    • Sci-Fi Books
    • Explore All Genre Guides
  • Books Like…
  • Reading Life
  • Seasonal Reading
  • Start HereExpand
    • Where to Start Reading
    • How This Site Works
Somewhere in These Pages
Historical Fiction | Historical Mystery | Mystery

The Lions of Fifth Avenue

UpdatedSeptember 28, 2026

Every product on this page was carefully chosen. I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through a link at no extra cost to you. See my full disclosure.

  • Share on Facebook

Author

Fiona Davis

Genre

Historical Fiction · Mystery

Published

2020

Series

Standalone

Setting

New York City · New York Public Library

Pages

384

Some books take you somewhere new. Others make you want to disappear completely into the place where they are set. The Lions of Fifth Avenue does both, taking readers inside the magnificent New York Public Library for a story of books, secrets, ambition, and family.

In 1913, Laura Lyons lives with her husband and children in an apartment hidden inside the New York Public Library, where her husband works as the library’s superintendent. But Laura wants a life beyond the traditional expectations placed on women, and studying journalism opens the door to a new world of ideas, independence, and possibility.

Eighty years later, Laura’s granddaughter Sadie is working as a curator at the same library when rare books and manuscripts begin disappearing. As Sadie investigates the thefts, she uncovers secrets surrounding her family’s past and a tragedy connected to the library itself.

...

Spanning two timelines and following two generations of women, The Lions of Fifth Avenue blends historical fiction, mystery, family secrets, and a love of books. At its heart is the New York Public Library itself — a magnificent setting filled with rare books, hidden spaces, literary history, and stories of its own.

The novel moves between 1913 and 1993, connecting Laura’s search for independence with Sadie’s investigation decades later. As the mysteries of the missing books begin to unravel, the two women’s stories become increasingly connected.

Why you’ll love it

A richly atmospheric historical mystery set inside the New York Public Library, with rare books, family secrets, two generations of women, and a fascinating glimpse into New York’s literary history. It’s the kind of book that makes the setting feel almost like another character.

Perfect for

Readers who love historical fiction, libraries, books about books, dual timelines, family secrets, literary mysteries, strong female characters, and stories where the setting is every bit as fascinating as the plot.

View on Amazon →

Where You’ll Find The Lions of Fifth Avenue on SITP

  • Best Books Set in NYC
  • Books About Libraries

What You’ll Find in This Book

  • Rare books and manuscripts
  • Two timelines connected by family secrets
  • Women finding independence in different eras
  • Literary mystery and intrigue
  • Atmospheric New York City
  • A fascinating behind-the-scenes look at a legendary library

The Vibe

  • Atmosphere: Literary · Atmospheric · Intriguing · Historical
  • Setting: New York City · New York Public Library · Greenwich Village
  • Mood: Mysterious · Bookish · Thoughtful · Suspenseful
  • Best read when: You want to disappear into a beautiful library and uncover a few secrets while you’re there.

Where Does The Lions of Fifth Avenue Take You?

Primarily to New York City, with the New York Public Library at the heart of the story.

The novel moves between the city’s early twentieth-century world and 1993, giving you two very different glimpses of New York while keeping the library at the centre of both stories. If you love books that make you feel as though you’ve stepped into a real place, this is one to add to your New York reading list.

  • Explore more books set in United States of America →
  • More books about Books →

You’ll Probably Love This If You Like…

  • Historical mysteries with a literary setting
  • Stories about libraries and rare books
  • Dual-timeline novels
  • Strong women navigating changing expectations
  • Family secrets revealed across generations
  • Atmospheric New York City settings
  • Books where the setting feels like a character

If You Like The Lions of Fifth Avenue, Try These Books

The Miniaturist by Jessie Burton
For another atmospheric historical novel where a fascinating setting, secrets, family, and beautifully detailed surroundings come together. Explore: The Miniaturist

The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova
If it is the combination of books, history, mystery, and a journey through fascinating places that appeals to you, The Historian is an excellent next read. Explore: The Historian

A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness
For another book where libraries, ancient texts, history, mystery, and academia become part of a much larger story. Explore: A Discovery of Witches

Keep Exploring

  • More historical mysteries
  • More dual-timeline stories

Ready to Read?

If you’re ready to step inside the New York Public Library and uncover its secrets, The Lions of Fifth Avenue is a wonderful choice for your reading list.

Buy the book: Amazon · Bookshop.org

Somewhere in These Pages

A book discovery system based on mood, era, and emotion.

Books
  • By Mood
  • By Era
  • By Location
  • By Genre
Book Guides
  • Books Like
  • Tropes Guide
  • Spice Guide
  • Slow Burn Guide
Start Here
  • Where to Start Reading
  • Best Books for New Readers
About
  • About This Site
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure

© 2026 Somewhere in These Pages

Facebook X Instagram

Powered by
Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
None
Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
None
Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
None
Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
None
Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
None
Powered by
  • Books by Mood
    • Emotional
    • Atmospheric
    • Explore All Books by Mood
  • Books by Era
    • Explore All Books By Era
  • Books By Location
    • Books Set in Spain
    • Books Set in Japan
    • Books Set in Greece
    • Books Set in Turkey
    • Explore All Books By Place
  • Books by Genre
    • Sci-Fi Books
    • Explore All Genre Guides
  • Books Like…
  • Reading Life
  • Seasonal Reading
  • Start Here
    • Where to Start Reading
    • How This Site Works
Search